TriggerFinger






BlogRoll

From the Barrel of a Gun
Lurking Rhythmically
Random Nuclear Strikes
Daily Pundit
Borepatch
Only Guns and Money
Mostly Cajun
Massad Ayoob
The View From North Central Idaho
Armed and Dangerous
Hell in a Handbasket
View From The Porch
Patterico
Guns, Cars, and Tech
Alphecca
Legal Insurrection
Irons in the Fire
Volokh Conspiracy
Snowflakes in Hell
Shot in the Dark
MArooned
Power Line
Michael Bane
Reason
The Smallest Minority
Publicola
Sharp as a Marble
The Silicon Greybeard
3 boxes of BS
Saysuncle
Alphecca
Of Arms and the Law
Bacon, Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, Explosives
Infodancer
Speculative Fiction
GunBlogBlackList
John Lott
Confiscation
IRS Scandal
Monster Hunter Nation

Most Popular

Featured Posts


Subscribe to Atom Feed

Tweets by @TriggerBlog


Make Custom Gifts at CafePress

Categories

FeedBoomershoot 2008 
FeedPolice Abuse 
FeedBoomershoot 2009 
Feed1st Amendment 
FeedCapital of the Free World 
FeedIllegal Mayors 
FeedBorder Control 
FeedFirearms 
FeedJury Nullification 
FeedHeller 
FeedCivil Rights 
FeedChicago Gun Case 
FeedWaco 
FeedParker 
FeedBenghazi 
FeedProperty Rights 
FeedAffirmative Action 
FeedZero Tolerance 
FeedSupreme Court 
FeedGeorge W Bush 
FeedVictimization Period 
FeedFalse-Flag Ops 
FeedConcealed Carry 
FeedSocial Security 
FeedConfiscation 
FeedGun Buy-Back 
FeedLibertarian Party 
FeedINDUCE Act 
FeedFree Speech 
FeedConstitution 
FeedArms Control 
FeedAssault Weapons 
FeedAtkins 
FeedDrug War 
FeedBudgetary Insanity 
FeedGoverningByConsent 
Feed2008 Elections 
FeedGilmore v Gonzales 
FeedBoomershoot 
FeedRegistration 
FeedTerrorism 
FeedImmigration 
FeedStand Your Ground 
FeedKonie v LA 
FeedLawsuits 
FeedBeretta 
FeedGovernment 
FeedMillion Mom March 
FeedFair Trial 
FeedBATF 
FeedEconomics 
FeedPrivacy 
FeedTrigger Locks 
FeedActivism 
Feed4th Amendment 
FeedAir Travel 
FeedSelf-Defense 
FeedCurrency 
FeedSamuel Alito 
Feed.50 Caliber Rifles 
FeedMiller 
FeedCampaign Finance 
Feed2004 Elections 
FeedEnvironment 
FeedLegal Filings 
FeedGun Show Loophole 
FeedThe Case of the .50-Caliber Felony 
FeedBean 
FeedAnti-Gun 
FeedCryptography 
FeedTaxation 
FeedCopyright 
FeedWiretaps 
FeedFast and Furious 
FeedEminent Domain 
FeedS1805 
FeedLiberty 
FeedMicrostamping 
FeedSchool Shootings 
FeedSurveillance 
FeedDMCA 
FeedCourt Rulings 
FeedHandguns 
FeedWesley Clark 
FeedDefensive Gun Use 
FeedMcDonald v Chicago 
FeedBrady 
FeedMedia Bias 
FeedHomeschooling 
FeedEmerson 
FeedRuby Ridge 
FeedRFID 
FeedSoftware Patents 
FeedRepublican Party 
FeedSeegars 
FeedBan 
FeedSilveira 
FeedIntellectual Property 
FeedArming America 
FeedMichael Badnarik 
FeedIRS Scandal 
FeedMilitia 
FeedPatriot Act 
FeedCAPPS-II 
FeedBackground checks 
Feed5th Amendment 
FeedEducation 
FeedArmed-Pilots 
FeedBallistic Fingerprinting 
Feed2nd Amendment 
FeedHiibel Case 
FeedFair Elections 
FeedSmart Guns 

Will the assault weapons ban rise from the dead?


One month and the AWB will be dead. Will it stay dead, or will it rise from the ashes like TIA and CAPPS II?

No Quarters thinks it will. And while it's possible that Congress will resurrect the law shortly after the elections, I doubt it will happen. I definitely don't think that the TIA/CAPPS-II fiascos will be similar. Why? Executive versus legislative branch.

Both CAPPS-II and TIA are programs run by the executive branch out of their existing budget (the Transportation Security Administration and the Pentagon, respectively) and under the ultimate administrative control of Bush. Bush, and/or his flunkies, wants both programs, and are willing to play shell games with the funding in order to keep them running. That's how they were "killed" and then "resurrected"; no legislative authorization is required to use the existing budgets on those programs. Congress must specifically de-authorize funds and must do so in a manner that is difficult to circumvent (eg, by changing the name of the program). They failed to do so with those two programs, perhaps deliberately.

Neither CAPS-II nor TIA are laws; they are enforcement mechanisms.

But the assault weapons ban is a law, not a program under an existing agency. When you don't have an agency with broad powers to regulate a certain industry, then you need to pass a law in order to mandate behavioral changes by the members of that industry (eg, "Do not manufacture assault weapons").

And that means that any renewal of the ban needs to get through Congress. We've already seen, in the past year or so, that getting a renewal through Congress is not easy. It may be easier after the election, when Congress no longer feels quite so at-risk about their election prospects, but it still won't be easy -- especially as we gun owners have made our presence felt powerfully in the Senate.

The real question is going to be: what happened in the election itself?

If the House successfully manages to avoid a vote on the ban, then the Democrats can't attack specific House members for voting against it. Neither can the Republicans attack the Democrats for voting for it. That favors the status quo for the Republicans in the House, which is not surprising since they have a large majority.

The Senate has already had votes on the ban. The Republicans will be watching to see what happens to Republicans who voted for the ban and will hope that Democrats who voted for it will lose their seats. If the yes-votes get punished appropriately, and especially if some seats change hands as a result, then we are likely safe for the immediate future.

On the other hand, if the election shows that the ban didn't matter to voters, we're likely to see the Democrats in the Senate make continued efforts to pass the ban. They want the law passed whether it wins them votes or not. Republicans aren't going to let it through unless they think it will win them votes, because they know it will hurt them with the gun owners. So in this scenario, look for a compromise bill (possibility the liability protection act again).


This entry was published 2005-09-24 10:43:35.0 by TriggerFinger and last updated 2005-09-24 10:43:35.0. [Tweet]

comments powered by Disqus

Recent Entries

Most Popular

Featured Entries

Related Categories

If you would like to receive new posts by email:

I am not a lawyer, and nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice. this site is run on custom blog software and is being actively developed. Please be forgiving of errors.


This website is an Amazon affiliate and will receive financial compensation for products purchased from Amazon through links on this site.