U.S. General Maps New Tactic to Pursue Taliban and Qaeda
According to the linked article, the military in Iraq has adopted a new tactic in the fight there: sending soldiers to live in the villages. But wait -- isn't there something in the Bill of Rights about that? Indeed there is: No Soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house, without the consent of the Owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law..
We don't know whether the soldiers have the "consent of the owner" in this case, but if they do not, and if Congress has not passed any laws specifically authorizing this tactic ("but in a manner to be prescribed by law", meaning, the military commander on the scene can't just make it up), then it seems we are faced with a clear violation of the Bill of Rights. And that's scary.
I don't expect Iraqi citizens to be familiar with this particularly obscure amendment. Nor, indeed, would most Americans recognize it unprompted. But the Iraqi resistance (much as I think they are on the wrong side) are in a situation very similar to the American colonies during the Revolutionary War. That is, they are resisting occupation by a foreign power. And, disturbingly, the United States proposes to respond with the same tactics the British used against us some two centuries ago.
And our Constitution does not specify that these rights are accessible only to US citizens, or within the borders of the US. The wording is any house, not any house in the United States, or any house owned by a US citizen.
At a minimum, to make this legal, Congress must pass specific laws authorizing and defining the practice. Whether those laws are valid is then a separator issue, since whether US law has jurisdiction over Iraq is an open question. (De facto, we control the territory; de jure, I'm not certain). And somehow, I doubt that Congress has found the time to pass anything specifically authorizing this tactic; they don't move fast enough.
So we are faced with a government that openly violating the Bill of Rights. What, then, are we to do?
I asked Jon Roland, who runs constitution.org, to comment on this issue:
Check the groups below and enter your email address to receive updates by email:
The trackback URL for this entry is: http://triggerfinger.org/weblog/servlet/trackback/4868
No trackbacks have been posted so far.
No comments have been posted so far.